where Metro Detroit moms meet
Change location »
1702 posts
Posted by PatS on Aug 15, 2008 at 02:42 PM
I am just curious. How do you feel about young men teaching the lower elementary grade, pre-k--3?
The school I teach at hired a new, very young, I don't think he's 25, male teacher to teach 3rd grade. For about 7 years they had a young man, probably in his twenties, who taught Kindergarten. (He has now left to be a principal at another school.)
Do you think it is appropriate or inappropriate for young men to be teaching the little ones? Do you think it is wrong? If so why? If not, why not.
I am just curious.
No one can make you feel inferior without your permission.
Send to Friends
Facebook
Publish to a group
229 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 02:52 PM
Don't teachers have to have a criminal background check?
If the teacher, male or female, can teach my child and not deter them from going to school, they can teach whatever grade they want to!
Jess
14 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 03:12 PM
My cousin's daughter had this teacher at OLMC, .and they seemed to like him. Personally, I think it's a little wierd. I think I'm stereo-typing. I'm guessing he took that job because it was the only one out there at the time, and it paid the bills until he came across a bigger and better job. Can you tell us at which school he will be principal? I'm curious because he's engaged to our Gym teacher at SACS. Thanks!
Mother of 2 Gentlemen-In-Training
218 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 04:21 PM
I think male teachers are awesome! My boys didn't have any until 4th grade, but I would have welcomed them earlier. I read an interesting story about how we are teaching our children to be afraid of men and how that may harm them later (both boys and girls). It concerns me a lot.
Support our Breast Cancer 3 Day Walking Team at http://08.the3day.org/goto/motorcitymoms
6994 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 04:28 PM
Good point MonkeyMom . . . but I have to admit that I'd react a little at first. I'd hope that I would make a quick enough recovery that no one would know. But you are right we are becoming very suspicious of men interacting with our children. And I think a male Kindergarten teacher would probably be fantastic!
Mother of 3 (Ages 7, 4, & 2) "From there to here, from here to there, funny things are everywhere." Dr. Seuss in "One Fish Two Fish Red Fish Blue Fish"
3993 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 05:09 PM
If the young man was just a gym teacher for the younger grades no one would question it at all. Some men are just as gifted with kids as women are. I think it would have been great for dd #1 to have a male teacher in K.
Need a sling? I have one just for you!
"One time at band camp......." American Pie
on Aug 15, 2008 at 05:53 PM
Thank you for your responses.
When I was a child, male teachers were virtually unheard of, except at the Jr. or Sr. high level. I do not recall my children having male teachers until they were in high school. But now I see more and more young men becoming elementary school teachers and some of them seek the "baby grades." I was just curious as to how modern moms felt about it.
I think it is great to have the male image at such a young age. Many children today do not have father-figures at home nor male role models. I think that a good, compassionate, caring man in their lives is necessary. Why not in the classrooom!
on Aug 15, 2008 at 06:25 PM
Okay Mom - yes we did. There was male teacher that tought 4/5/6 when we were in those grades. Although as a teacher I'm sure he was fairly forgetable!
2605 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 07:28 PM
I agree with Pat......
I think it is great that more men are becoming teachers for the younger grades. In my opinion a child can never have too many positive role models in their lives. Too many children grow up without a positive male role model these days ( I am not counting children who have the benefit of an involved granddad, uncle, step dad..etc). I did kind of feel sorry for some of the men teachers in the district where my kids went...year after year they were given the most difficult children to teach, the majority of whom had no father figure in their life. It was then that we could say “thank God for Mr. Young Man teacher, he probably saved that kid” You know so many are worried about young male teachers being perverts....read/watch the news and all you hear about are the women teachers after all the young boys...
All who wander probably ARE lost....koby's mere
24 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 07:51 PM
I think they are fantastic, my kids aren't in school yet, but my BIL is also a third or fifth ??? (he's taught both) grade teacher, and he is fantastic with kids!! My young ones and the older ones! He's even really good with my brother who is a teenager!!!!!
1804 posts
on Aug 15, 2008 at 08:26 PM
Great point about being a male role model for those kids that don't have one, Pat! I had a couple of male teachers in grades 4 & 5 & they were among my favorites. I also think that boys tend to learn differently than girls (& the way schools are set up to teach) & male teachers can relate to that better & may have an easier time tweaking their teaching methods to account for that.
Rebecca
(Note: Replies are posted to all groups where this topic has been shared.)
Already a member?
Not yet a member?
by HappyGirl72 in General Discussion
Morning all . . . it's that time of year again . ...
Last reply by Sue1 on Nov 21 at 1:43 PM
by KristaJahnke in My Stories
We're doing a question each day randomly pulled fr..
Last reply by HappyGirl72 on Nov 21 at 1:30 PM
by Tylersmommy in 4-12 Year Olds
"Miss Rebecca" "Miss Rebecca" "Miss Rebecca!..
Last reply by HappyGirl72 on Nov 21 at 1:26 PM
by coco958 in Roll Call (Detroit!)
Ahhh the weekend, there aren't enough days in it....
Last reply by HappyGirl72 on Nov 21 at 1:24 PM
by ModMamaKristinT in Living Beautifully For Less
http://www.iwillteachyoutoberich.....
Posted on Nov 21 at 1:05 PM
by Tylersmommy in My Stories
Normal 0 false false false MicrosoftInternetExplo..
Posted on Nov 21 at 12:22 PM
by CinderMomma in Breastfeeding
Okay so I had a lot of problems getting baby to la..
Last reply by CinderMomma on Nov 21 at 11:40 AM
by NannisBaby in Babies & Toddlers
My DD is 15-months and just started walking a mont..
Last reply by NannisBaby on Nov 21 at 11:33 AM
by athleteintraining in Recipes, Meals, Snacks
Okay, I know some of you are going to think these ..
Last reply by cmgrayson1 on Nov 21 at 11:28 AM
by bedebede in TEEN SCENE
What should we talk about on the six hour drive ho..
Last reply by cmgrayson1 on Nov 21 at 11:26 AM
See more discussions
Email us at detroit@momslikeme.com
Copyright©2009 Detroit MomsLikeMe.com. All rights reserved. Users of this site agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights, Terms updated June 2009.